In a pivotal legal proceeding on Tuesday, a lawyer for the voting technology firm Smartmatic argued that top leaders at Fox News, specifically Rupert and Lachlan Murdoch, sanctioned a conscious plan to adopt baseless claims of election fraud promoted by Donald Trump.
“The conservative viewers, their bread and butter, deserted them,” stated J Erik Connolly, the company's attorney. “So what do they do? They return back to what they know best: they return back to disinformation, political propaganda and xenophobia. The election narrative and the fraud allegations were the perfect vehicle for them to return to their central messaging.”
A Multi-Billion Dollar Libel Case Hangs in the Balance
During courtroom presentations, both parties pleaded with Judge David B Cohen to decide on essential elements of Smartmatic's $2.7 billion legal action ahead of a possible trial next year. The company maintains that Fox leaders devised a plan to “pivot” to the former president's allegations to win back disaffected viewers.
Fox's Vehement Denial
A lawyer for Fox News, speaking for the network, strongly contested these accusations. “No disinformation campaign was ordered,” he said. “It is total bunk. It is not supported by the record. It is hogwash. It was fabricated by lawyers on the other side.”
He further asserted that the Murdochs, who held ultimate control over the network, “didn't give anyone any orders to cover Smartmatic or the election fraud allegations.”
The Core Legal Hurdle: Proving “Actual Malice”
For Smartmatic to prevail, the company must prove that key figures at Fox News knew the allegations lacked truth but allowed them to be aired regardless. Through legal motions, Smartmatic has pointed to private messages showing hosts like Jeanine Pirro and Maria Bartiromo voicing skepticism about the claims while also showing an interest to help Trump.
The network's attorney countered that Smartmatic has “grossly exaggerated” its worth and the estimated financial losses from the broadcasts. Fox contends its hosts were merely reporting on newsworthy claims from the president's allies, not promoting them.
“This lawsuit really isn't about Fox's coverage of the 2020 election,” the Fox lawyer stated. “It concerns Smartmatic's effort to capitalize on remarks made by the president's lawyers to rescue its business viability.”
A Precedent Is Highly Relevant
The arguments strongly resemble the successful defamation lawsuit brought by Dominion Voting Systems against Fox. In that case, a judge's pre-trial rulings proved critical, finding that Fox's broadcasts were untrue and defamatory per se.
That ruling was later cited as a key factor in Fox's choice to resolve with Dominion for $787.5 million. A previous Fox legal officer noted that the judge's pre-trial rulings had “severely limited” the company's legal defense at trial.
The Judge's Stance
Judge Cohen offered few hints of his leaning but informed Smartmatic's lawyer that establishing “actual malice” for a summary judgment would be a “hard sell.” He stated he intended to examine all pertinent broadcasts before making a decision.
“I believe I have sufficient information, evidence, briefings, diagrams, charts and all I need to reach a verdict,” he told the two sides in the lawsuit.